Every exchange is scored on the same six US criteria. Each criterion is calculated from dated facts by the fixed rule below, the weighted result on 10 points, shown as stars out of 5. Facts come from the provider’s own pages and public market data, from regulators, and only where those leave a gap from at least two agreeing independent reviews. Commissions and partnerships do not change a score.
- Costs (25%): What it costs to buy $500 of XRP and sell it again on the path a new account lands on, funded by ACH: up to $5 = 10, up to $8 = 9, up to $10 = 8, up to $15 = 7, up to $20 = 6, up to $25 = 5, up to $30 = 4; above that, 3. A cost that is published only as a range or a limit is scored at its upper bound, and a simple path that does not publish both its fee and its spread loses a point. An advanced interface with a roundtrip of $10 or less adds a point.
- Oversight and custody (20%): Starts at 3. +2 for a New York licence, +1 for state licences wherever it serves customers, +1 for FinCEN registration, +1 for audited public financial statements, +1 for proof of reserves within twelve months, +1 for crypto held for the customer under the US agreement. An incident in the last five years in which customers lost funds without being reimbursed takes 2 points, a customer data incident 1 point.
- State availability (15%): 10 when the provider’s US terms exclude no state; each state without crypto trading takes a point, down to 3.
- Features (15%): Starts at 4, plus 1 each for recurring buys, an advanced interface, staking, free ACH deposits, withdrawal to your own wallet and Form 1099-DA.
- Asset selection (15%): Assets offered to US customers: at least 300 = 10, at least 200 = 9, at least 150 = 8, at least 100 = 7, at least 50 = 6, at least 25 = 5; fewer, 3. A point less when XRP is not offered in every state the provider serves.
- App and support (10%): The US App Store rating doubled, at most 9, counted with at least 10,000 ratings (otherwise 5); plus 1 for live help around the clock.
We hold no US account, so the score rests on published facts rather than on our own orders. Hardware-wallet scores describe the original product reviews. Third-party user ratings, where shown, carry their own scale and review date.
